Flooring The Consumer on Simple Marketing Now

Please visit Flooring The Consumer's new home on SimpleMarketingNow.com where you can subscribe to receive updates to blog articles in real time!

Wednesday, October 18, 2006

What Makes a Destination?

My retail experience 'treat' - which started with Retail Experience and the Human Element - continues with a focus on what makes a retail experience a destination.

In other words, why would you go out of your way to visit a retail store given all of the choices available? Certainly, how well you are treated plays a big role. And how special the retail environment matters, too. But, another aspect has to do with the uniqueness of the products and consistency of the merchandising. Or, a passion for the mission.

I was excited to finally experience Zara 5th Avenue [I walked past another on 59th by Lexington later] . I first learned about Zara from a November 2004 Harvard Business Review article [titled "Rapid Fire Fulfillment"]. And, earlier this year at the Envirosell "Science of Shopping" conference, Paco Underhill introduced Jose Luis Nueno, marketing professor at Spain's IESE business school, to talk about Zara [he sits on the board of Zara and several other European 'powerhouse merchants'].

Zara is remarkable for being absolutely on top of the fashion game with the most efficient supply chain system in the world - it can develop, make and deliver anywhere around the world a new apparel style in 15 days! It has created a means of rapidly responding to changing customer preferences via an amazing store communications system. This enables the company to get feedback on new styles [10,000 new introductions per year] to decide whether to ramp up or down on production runs. Part of their secret - which goes against conventional practices - is to limit product supply, and constantly replenish with new products. In other words, deliver 'fast fashion'.

Do read Andrea Learned's posting titled " Women Buy Zara's Scarcity" which will point you to a February 2005 HBR archive on Zara. Do also check out the Zara website which offers a marvelous visual display of many of its store fronts and store windows around the world, and even discusses the latest fashion trends.

I thoroughly enjoyed the store: elegant, with a European fashion feel, and fun Spanish music pulsing throughout. Product did indeed look unique, wearable, well made yet not stratospherically priced! I liked the variety and quantity of garments available: enough to be interesting and showcase different styles, but not so many that I felt overwhelmed. I checked out both women's wear floors. The store offered wonderful oases of space to allow the consumer to better absorb and internalize the choices. I felt welcome and look forward to returning to investigate further.

- A quick dash through the Disney Store 55th/5th Avenue. I definitely need to give this store more time. I became quickly overwhelmed with all of the Disney theater effects - music, lighting, unbelievably elaborate costumes [with high price tags] and had to get out for air. I plan on returning with a member of the target audience [5 year old girl]! Check out the website; it effectively showcases how unique this store is compared to the mall based stores, as well as the DisneyLand/World stores. I have high expectations that this store does a good job linking emotionally to the NYC based Disney productions.

- Toys R Us, Times Square: yes, the Ferris Wheel is impressive! As I entered, a Toys R Us employee took my picture and said I could check it out in 10-15 minutes. A few steps further and a circus ringmaster wouldn't have been out of place given the strong sense of 'let the entertainment begin!' Toy demonstrations, employees with silly hats... It reminded me of what I imagine old style retailing to be like.

On the 2nd floor, I saw the gigantic Lego dinosaur. Impressive, but I had seen it last summer. Shouldn't that change? I needed some directions and had to interrupt 2 salespeople for help. Oops, I definitely bothered them. Now, mind you, it was approx. 10:15am on a weekday and I was a customer. Right? Made it past the Thomas the tank engine section with a large interactive kids play tables, and then found the Barbie Boutique.

The Barbie Boutique is supposed to be a big deal - 2 stories with all things Barbie. A celebration of sorts, right? Wrong. I noticed sales signs everywhere. I expected to find a deep assortment of all products associated with the Barbie brand extensions. Not. I expected to find a place where all of the fancy castles are displayed for inspection and play. Not. I expected something exciting on the 2nd floor of this unusual store within a store, something that recaptured the magical playhouses of childhood. Not! Rather it was uninviting and unengaging; no magic, no soul. No passion!

And it's not just in the Barbie area.

I went down to check out my picture; it wasn't yet ready. Do you know that they wanted $13 for a copy? or $25 for a digital file!!!! Hmmm. I might have felt better about the photo had I been asked if I had a camera. I originally thought the photo idea was a nice touch, but why so expensive? Just because I'm a captive audience? Seems the photo can also appear on a marquee, but no one really explained the various options available. It wound up making me angry and suspicious of the store's motives and it all seemed really amateurish: the young woman at the photo desk thought she could refer me to a website to decide later [Disney does that], but she couldn't locate one. I learned that with the $25 I was eligible for a discount on a purchase. Now, wouldn't a consumer want to know this before leaving the store?

Here's another point of frustration - make sure to integrate your website with your physical store: I later visited the Toys R Us website. It had little to do with how the store was organized. I called the NYC store, left a message [no live person available] and a week later I'm still waiting for someone to return my call. I guess they don't want my business. By the way, I found what I was looking for on eBay, and have already received it.

For a so-called destination or flagship, this was a so-so retail experience. Cool ferris wheel, but I have plenty of other more satisfying options available.

As I think about which of these stores were truly Destination Stores, I realize that Zara offered me the most unique and differentiated product selection in an environment that passionately believes in its mission: Fast Fashion. Urban Outfitters in Retail Experience and the Human Element conveyed passion and uniqueness in its desire to create an engaging consumer environment: it made me want to stay and browse. These 2 stores are not flagship stores; they represent one of several in the NYC area. Yet, they have managed to create a desireable retail environment as a normal course of business whereas two of the flagship stores I visited had issues - with the human element and the un-integrated, uninspired merchandising.

So, if it isn't necessary to be a flagship to be a Destination, then any store truly committed to showcasing passion for product and experience qualifies, including carpet and flooring stores!

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,


Anonymous said...

It is great to hear about great retailers, but throw in a flooring store once in a while.

CB Whittemore said...

Thanks for your comment and suggestion. I am constantly on the lookout for great flooring stores and welcome your input. Feel free to add your perspective to this conversation.

Post a Comment

Reminder: Please, no self-promotional or SPAM comments. Don't bother if you're simply trying to build inauthentic link juice. Finally, don't be anonymous: it's too hard to have a conversation. Thanks, CB

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...